Bad Decisions

Catastrophes, blunders and moments people really should have known better.

17 episodes

The Doctor Who Tried to Steal Hawaii, and the Secret That Changed the Cold War

On 19 July 1817, German doctor Georg Anton Schäffer was expelled from Kauaʻi after a spectacular two-year attempt to claim the Hawaiian Islands for the Russian Empire without any authority to do so. He built three forts, raised the Russian flag, and drafted treaties with a local king hoping to escape Kamehameha’s dominance, but the promised warships never came. Fast forward to 19 July 1981, when French President François Mitterrand handed Ronald Reagan the Farewell Dossier in Ottawa, revealing a massive Soviet operation to steal Western technology. The CIA’s response involved feeding the KGB subtly sabotaged secrets, including pipeline software that may have caused one of the largest non-nuclear explosions ever recorded. Seven years later, on 19 July 1988, Bruce Springsteen performed for up to 300,000 people at the largest concert in East German history, speaking about barriers coming down sixteen months before the Berlin Wall fell. And in 2003, surgeons in Vienna completed the world’s first successful tongue transplant, restoring speech and taste through fourteen hours of surgery involving over thirty specialists. Four stories of human ambition, geopolitical manoeuvring, cultural defiance, and medical innovation, all sharing the same date in history.

Read & listen →

Netscape Dies, Mozilla Is Born, and Nintendo Changes Gaming Forever

On 15 July 2003, AOL Time Warner quietly shut down Netscape, the browser that once commanded 90% of the market. On the same day, the Mozilla Foundation opened its doors as an independent non-profit, carrying forward the open-source code Netscape had released in 1998. That code would become Firefox, challenge Internet Explorer, and influence the modern web as we know it. Twenty years earlier, on 15 July 1983, Nintendo released the Famicom in Japan, a small red and white console that would become the NES and establish the template for platform gaming worldwide. And on 15 July 1996, a Belgian Air Force C-130 Hercules crashed on approach to Eindhoven Airport in the Netherlands, killing 34 people, including members of the Royal Netherlands Army marching band. Three moments on one date: a browser that died to give birth to something better, a console that rewrote the rules of play, and 34 lives lost in an accident that still marks the calendar with grief.

Read & listen →

When George Bush Was President for Eight Hours

On 13 July 1985, Vice President George H. W. Bush became Acting President of the United States for approximately eight hours whilst Ronald Reagan underwent surgery under general anaesthetic. It was the first time the Twenty-Fifth Amendment’s provisions for voluntary transfer of power had been used in practice, if not technically invoked. Bush spent his brief tenure playing golf in Maine, a masterclass in constitutional restraint. The episode also explores a failed 2003 French intelligence operation to rescue hostage Íngrid Betancourt from FARC guerrillas, the 645 CE Isshi Incident that reshaped Japanese imperial politics through assassination and reform, and the 1925 discovery of the Venus of Dolní Věstonice, one of the oldest known ceramic objects in the world, dating back some 26,000 to 31,000 years. From presidential procedures to ice age artistry, the thirteenth of July offers a cross-section of human decision-making at its most careful, most violent, and most enduring.

Read & listen →

Frobisher's Ghost Island, El Chapo's Tunnel, and the First Phone Photo

On 11 July across three centuries, three men made their mark through confidence, ingenuity, and technological ambition. In 1576, explorer Martin Frobisher sighted Greenland but mistakenly identified it as Frisland, a non-existent island shown on the influential but fictional Zeno Map. His error illuminates the challenges of 16th-century navigation and the consequences of cartographic fiction. In 2015, drug lord Joaquín ‘El Chapo’ Guzmán escaped Mexico’s Altiplano maximum security prison through a sophisticated 1.5-kilometre tunnel, exposing security failures and triggering an international manhunt. In 1997, Philippe Kahn shared the first photograph from a mobile phone, an image of his newborn daughter sent while waiting in a California hospital, prefiguring the instant visual communication now used by billions daily. Three stories of exploration, escape, and innovation reveal the enduring human capacity for ambition, both misguided and transformative.

Read & listen →

The 1,720-Foot Wave That Rewrote the Science Books

On 10 July 1958, a magnitude 7.9 earthquake triggered the largest wave in recorded history. Ninety million tons of rock crashed into Lituya Bay, Alaska, sending water surging 1,720 feet up the mountainside, stripping trees and soil in a single catastrophic event. Three fishing boats were caught in the bay that night. Two crews survived against impossible odds. One did not. The megatsunami redefined what scientists believed water could do and remains the defining case study in coastal hazard modelling. Also on this day: French intelligence agents sank the Greenpeace vessel Rainbow Warrior in Auckland Harbour in 1985, killing one photographer and sparking an international scandal. And in 2018, the final four members of a Thai youth football team emerged from the Tham Luang cave system after 18 days underground, completing one of the most remarkable rescue operations of the century. Clara Vale explores a day when history arrived as a wall of water, a covert bombing, and a moment of extraordinary human coordination.

Read & listen →

The Man Who Fell 2,400 Metres and Lived

On 9 July 1997, engineer Fernando Caldeira de Moura Campos was ejected from an exploding TAM Airlines Fokker 100 at 2,400 metres altitude over Brazil, without a parachute. Against all odds, he survived the fall. This episode also examines Earth’s shortest recorded day on 9 July 2025, when the planet’s rotation ran 1.3 to 1.6 milliseconds fast, raising the prospect of a negative leap second. We revisit the 1985 Austrian wine scandal, when producers were caught adulterating wine with diethylene glycol, an antifreeze component, leading to collapsed exports and ultimately some of the world’s strictest wine regulations. Finally, we return to 9 July 2006, when Zinédine Zidane headbutted Marco Materazzi in the World Cup final, ending his career with a red card rather than a trophy. Four stories of survival, precision, scandal, and one very public loss of composure.

Read & listen →

Broomsticks, Border Controls, and Three Presidents in One Day

On 8 July across different years, history delivered a masterclass in human ambition, catastrophic misjudgement, and bureaucratic precision. In 2012, Oxford hosted the first Quidditch World Cup held outside the United States, as a sport invented in a fantasy novel became a genuine international competition complete with broomsticks and world champions. In 1998, a French customs stop uncovered hundreds of doping products in a team car, triggering the Festina Affair that nearly ended that year’s Tour de France and exposed systematic drug use in professional cycling. In 2014, Brazil suffered the Mineiraço, losing 7-1 to Germany in a World Cup semi-final at home in what remains one of football’s most shocking results. And in 2010, Poland managed three different presidents in a single day through perfectly legal constitutional succession following the Smolensk air disaster. From fictional sports made real to sporting dreams destroyed, the eighth of July proves that history arrives in many forms, most of them unexpected.

Read & listen →

The Staffordshire Hoard and the Stolen Codex Calixtinus

On 5 July 2009, unemployed metal detectorist Terry Herbert began unearthing over 1,500 pieces of Anglo-Saxon gold and silver from a Staffordshire field, the largest hoard of its kind ever found in Britain. The discovery, made with a £2.50 second-hand detector, transformed understanding of early medieval England and revealed military treasures of astonishing craftsmanship from the warrior kingdom of Mercia. Exactly two years later, on 5 July 2011, staff at Santiago de Compostela Cathedral noticed the disappearance of the Codex Calixtinus, a twelfth-century illuminated manuscript and the world’s first guidebook to the Camino pilgrimage route. The international investigation led to the arrest of a cathedral electrician who had stolen the irreplaceable manuscript along with other treasures. Both stories illuminate the tension between what we bury, what we lose, and what we find again, whether after a millennium or a single year.

Read & listen →

The Barony of Arizona: How to Steal Eleven Million Acres with Fake Documents

On 28 June 1895, a United States court delivered a verdict that ended one of the most audacious land frauds in American history. James Addison Reavis had spent over a decade claiming ownership of roughly eleven million acres of Arizona, armed with forged documents, a fabricated Spanish aristocratic title, and a wife he had specifically coached to play the role of Baroness. He had altered genuine historical archives across two continents, sold quit-claim deeds to major businesses, and convinced the world that the Barony of Arizona was real. It was not. Today, Clare Vale unpacks the spectacular rise and meticulous unravelling of the Peralta Grant, alongside the 1997 boxing match where Mike Tyson bit Evander Holyfield’s ear, the 1911 Martian meteorite that landed in Egypt, and the surprisingly modest origins of the modern dog show in Newcastle upon Tyne. History, as ever, rewards confidence, until someone checks the paperwork.

Read & listen →

Shirley Jackson's 'The Lottery' Sparks Unrest

In 1948, a short story by Shirley Jackson titled ‘The Lottery’ shook readers to their core. Published in The New Yorker, this tale of a seemingly benign small-town lottery with a shocking twist left audiences bewildered and led to a flurry of protests and subscription cancellations. The story’s unsettling commentary on blind tradition and conformity resonated powerfully in post-war America. Its impact has endured, solidifying its place as a classic in American literature. Shifting gears, we also explore the achievements of the Flying Scotsman locomotive, which set speed records in the 1920s, symbolising British engineering prowess. Finally, we delve into the signing of the United Nations Charter in 1945, a landmark event aimed at fostering global peace in the aftermath of World War Two.

Read & listen →

The Woman Who Made History in a Cathedral Full of Witnesses

On 25 June 1678, Elena Cornaro Piscopia became the first woman in recorded history to be awarded a doctorate of philosophy. The ceremony took place in the Cathedral of the Blessed Virgin in Padua because so many people arrived to witness it that the university’s halls could not contain them. Born into a Venetian noble family in 1646, Elena was fluent in seven languages, a published theologian, accomplished musician, and Benedictine oblate. When her father proposed her for a doctorate in theology, the Bishop of Padua objected, so she was examined in philosophy instead. She answered her examiners in Latin and was awarded the degree with distinction. She died four years later at age thirty-eight, and the University of Padua did not award another doctorate to a woman for three decades. Also on this date: the 1982 Disgrace of Gijón, when West Germany and Austria played a World Cup match so obviously fixed that FIFA changed its rules permanently; the first known photojournalistic image, taken during the violent June Days Uprising in Paris in 1848; and the 1900 discovery of the Dunhuang manuscripts, tens of thousands of ancient texts sealed in a cave for nine hundred years.

Read & listen →

Daring Walks, Typewriters, and Transformative Pills

Join Clara Vale as she navigates through some of history’s most compelling moments. From Nik Wallenda’s nerve-wracking tightrope walk over the Grand Canyon in 2013 to the invention of the ‘Type-Writer’ in 1868 by Christopher Latham Sholes, we explore feats of courage and innovation. We dive into the shadows of the Watergate scandal, revisiting Nixon’s pivotal misstep in 1972, and recognise IBM’s 1969 decision that shaped today’s software industry by pricing software separately from hardware. Finally, we celebrate the approval of Enovid by the FDA in 1960, a revolutionary development in personal freedom. In our journey, witness human ambition and its eventual impacts on society.

Read & listen →

The Fireman Who Sat on the Safety Valve and the Last Sparrow

On 17 June 1831, the Best Friend of Charleston, America’s first commercially built steam locomotive, exploded after a fireman sat on its safety valve to silence the hissing. The blast killed the fireman, injured the engineer, and destroyed the locomotive. The South Carolina Canal and Rail Road Company rebuilt it as the Phoenix and introduced cotton bale buffers between engine and passengers, an early attempt at railway safety. Meanwhile, 156 years later on the same date, a small bird called Orange Band died at Walt Disney World. He was the last dusky seaside sparrow, a victim of habitat destruction, pesticide use, and delayed conservation efforts. Both stories centre on warnings ignored: the hiss of a valve designed to prevent disaster, and the slow disappearance of a species no one noticed until it was too late. Clara Vale tells the story of human overconfidence, new technology, and the cost of not listening when systems try to speak.

Read & listen →

Episode 10 8 min

The Captain Who Survived Being Sucked Out of His Own Cockpit

On 10 June 1990, British Airways Flight 5390 departed Birmingham for Malaga with a catastrophic flaw: a cockpit windscreen secured with the wrong bolts. Thirteen minutes into the flight, the panel blew out at 23,000 feet, dragging Captain Tim Lancaster headfirst through the opening. Flight attendant Nigel Ogden grabbed his legs and held on through 500-mile-per-hour winds and sub-zero temperatures, whilst co-pilot Alastair Atchison executed an emergency landing at Southampton with a captain dangling outside the aircraft. All 81 people aboard survived. The episode also marks the 1935 founding of Alcoholics Anonymous, when Dr Bob Smith took his last drink in Akron, Ohio, and recalls Kevin Warwick’s 2002 neural communication experiment and fifteen-year-old Joe Nuxhall’s chaotic 1944 baseball debut. A day of extraordinary human resilience in the face of impossible circumstances.

Read & listen →

Episode 9 9 min

A Reporter's Secret Life and the Question That Broke McCarthy

On 9 June 1930, Chicago Tribune reporter Jake Lingle was shot dead in a crowded pedestrian tunnel beneath Michigan Avenue. The Tribune launched a crusade, declaring him a journalistic martyr murdered for asking too many questions. Within weeks, the truth emerged: Lingle had been living far beyond his reporter’s salary, maintaining close ties to Al Capone, and allegedly owed the gangster’s organisation $100,000 in gambling debts. Twenty-four years later, on 9 June 1954, another kind of reckoning arrived. In a televised Senate hearing watched by millions, Boston lawyer Joseph Welch confronted Senator Joseph McCarthy with a question that became famous: ‘Have you no sense of decency, sir, at long last?’ The moment is widely credited as the turning point that broke McCarthy’s power. Clara Vale explores two very different stories about accountability, the difference between access and independence, and the moments when someone finally asks the question everyone else has been thinking.

Read & listen →

Episode 5 9 min

The Last Transit of Venus and the Stories of 5 June

On 5 June 2012, millions watched Venus cross the face of the Sun for the last time in any living person’s lifetime. The next transit won’t occur until 2117. This rare celestial event once sent Captain Cook to Tahiti in 1769 and helped unlock the true scale of the solar system. But the fifth of June holds other remarkable stories: in 1983, the Soviet cruise ship Aleksandr Suvorov collided catastrophically with a railway bridge on the Volga River, killing over a hundred passengers. In 1995, physicists at the University of Colorado created the first Bose-Einstein condensate, a state of matter predicted by Einstein seventy years earlier. In 1956, Elvis Presley’s hip-swivelling performance of Hound Dog on The Milton Berle Show scandalised critics and ignited rock and roll on primetime television. And in 1949, Orapin Chaiyakan became the first woman elected to Thailand’s Parliament. From planetary mechanics to cultural flashpoints, this episode explores the moments that still resonate from a single day in history.

Read & listen →

Episode 3 9 min

The Last Great Auks and the Collectors Who Killed Them

On 3 June 1844, three Icelandic fishermen landed on the remote volcanic island of Eldey and killed the last confirmed breeding pair of great auks. The birds were strangled, their skins sold to a collector, and their egg cracked and abandoned. The species had survived ice ages and geological upheaval, but vanished within centuries of sustained human contact. What makes the extinction particularly stark is that it was not driven by necessity or ignorance. By the 1840s, naturalists and hunters alike knew the great auk was nearly gone, yet this rarity made specimens more valuable to museums and private collections, creating a market incentive that accelerated the final decline. Clare Vale explores this moment of documented extinction alongside other events from 3 June, including Chinese official Lin Zexu’s destruction of over a million kilograms of British opium in 1839, the 1969 collision between HMAS Melbourne and USS Frank E. Evans that killed 74 American sailors, and the founding of Barcelona’s Academy of the Distrustful in 1700, a scholarly society built on intellectual scepticism.

Read & listen →